Options
Baker, Alister
- PublicationThe Market for Animal-Source Foods in Uganda: Looking Beyond Quantity: Rapid Apprasial of Consumer Preferences for Retail Outlets, Retail Forms and Safety and Quality AttributesThis paper presents the results of a rapid consumer survey undertaken in Uganda. The survey aimed at identifying preferred quality and safety attributes, retail forms and retail outlets for major livestock products and by type of consumers. Results of the survey, combined with nationally representative household datasets, allows description of both the quantitative and qualitative dimensions of the developing market for animal-source foods, which is anticipated to provide major business opportunities for small-scale livestock producers in the short and medium terms.
- PublicationAdministrative Records for Official Statistics: Food for Thought on Uganda's Livestock Data(Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatistica, 2013)
;Okello, Julius ;Sserruga, Joseph ;Pica-Ciamarra, UgoThis paper presents a methodology to rapidly assess routine livestock data systems and identify options for improvement. The methodology has been developed by the Uganda Ministry of Agriculture, Animal Industry and Fisheries (MAAIF) and the Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS) in collaboration with the FAO-World Bank-ILRI-Africa Union Inter African Bureau for Animal Resources (AU-IBAR) Livestock Data Innovation in Africa Project. Uganda, as several other developing countries, does have a system of routine data collection which explicitly targets livestock. The paper describes the routine livestock data system of Uganda; presents and applies to Uganda a methodology to rapidly assess livestock administrative records; and suggests options for improvement, with a focus on 'field experiment' or pilots with control groups as effective ways to promote institutional changes in the system of routine livestock data collection. - PublicationBusiness and Livelihoods in African Livestock: Investments to overcome information gaps(World Bank, 2014)
;Pica-Ciamarra, Ugo; ;Morgan, Nancy ;Ly, Cheik ;Nouala, Simplice ;World BankUnited Nations, Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)Poverty is widespread in Africa, but the continent is fast growing, with the consumption of animal protein skyrocketing, in particular for relatively low-value, low-processed livestock products. Meanwhile, in rural areas, the majority of households are livestock keepers, many of whom are poor. This growth in demand for animal protein can provide major business opportunities for livestock producers, with implications for poverty reduction. While there is heterogeneity among livestock keepers, clustering them into homogenous groups is useful to guide policy and investment decisions that stimulate a market-driven and inclusive growth of the sector. A small share of livestock keepers, from between 5 to 20 percent, depending on the country, can be considered business-oriented with incentives to expand their livestock production and tap into the growing market for animal protein. These keep relative large herds and derive a significant share of their cash income from accessing and utilizing livestock markets. The remainder of livestock keepers can be defined as livelihood-oriented: they keep animals more for the many livelihoods services they provide - such as insurance, manure and hauling services - than for selling meat, milk and other livestock products to the market. The reason is simple: on average, they keep 1.60 Tropical Livestock Units (TLUs), which is equivalent to about three beef cattle per household or about 0.6 TLU per household member, and, therefore, they cannot derive large benefits from regularly selling their surplus production to the market. Policies and investments aimed at enhancing the contribution of livestock to economic growth and poverty reduction should consequently adopt a dual strategy of targeting livelihood-oriented and business-oriented livestock keepers, who have diverse incentives to keep animals. There are, however, major information gaps which constrain the formulation of effective policy and investment decisions. - PublicationData and indicators for evidence-based livestock sector policies and investmentsLivestock sector policies' and investments' effectiveness is enhanced by their evidence base. However, the lack of mainstream literature on the information needs of decision-makers makes it difficult to appreciate the data and indicators necessary for effective policies and investments. This review systematizes the types of data and indicators that decision-makers need for effectively formulating and implementing policies and investments in the livestock sector through the various phases of the decision-making process. These span the large set of tasks associated with assessing the contribution of livestock to development, to identifying priority areas of investments, to monitoring and evaluation. Six domains for such data are identified and discussed, with key contributions from the literature identified. Basic data and indicators provide critical information to decision-makers, with statistical analyses linking inputs and outputs further improving the decision-making processes. However, these are rarely readily available to draft an evidence based policy implementation plan. Indeed, the implementation of policy reforms and investments usually co-occurs with some form of institutional change - new ways of doing things - which calls for changed behaviours for both implementers and beneficiaries. Elements of a statistical system that is largely effective in promoting sustainable development of the livestock sector generally is one that generates good quality livestock data and indicators representative of the country as a whole and major livestock production systems, uses inclusive participatory policy processes and consultation with experts, synthesizes existing experience and analysis, and uses both rigorous ex ante analysis and pilots to assist decision-makers in designing and executing policies and investments, and implementing monitoring and evaluation.
- PublicationIntegrating livestock into agricultural statistics: The AU-IBAR, FAO, ILRI, WB Data Innovation Project(Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), 2010)
;Pica-Ciamarra, Ugo; ;Bedane, Berhanu ;Emwanu, ThomasMorgan, NancyThe growing demand for food of animal origin developing countries, stimulated by population growth, gains in real per capita income and urbanization, represents an opportunity for some livestock dependent poor to escape poverty. However, because of the dearth of livestock-related data, the linkages between livestock, economic development and poverty reduction remain to a large extent unclear, which constrains the design, implementation and monitoring of pro-poor livestockrelated policies and investments. This paper provides an introduction to the Gates-funded Livestock in Africa: Improving Data for Better Policies Project being implemented by AU-IBAR, FAO, ILRI and WB. This project has the overarching objective to assist African governments in better collecting and analyzing data which support public and private investments in the livestock sector that benefit the less well-to-do.
A variety of livestock-related data can be collected at country level, but the current limited understanding of the livestock-poverty interface makes it difficult to identify priority data to gather and process for formulating policies and investments which promote equitable growth of the livestock sector. In addition, the role and mandate of the public sector in providing specific information is often unclear, and stakeholders tend to look for data and indicators which support specific investments or government objectives - such as, for example, the number of livestock to be vaccinated or prices for live animals in major regional markets - often disregarding the broader livestock-poverty interface. There are also technical difficulties associated with 'measuring livestock', due to the existence of hundreds of breeds; regular and irregular herd mortality and reproduction rate; livestock movements; impact of livestock age and animal diseases on productivity; and others.
The Livestock in Africa: Improving Data for Better Policies Project will inventory existing livestock-poverty data and data sources in Uganda, Tanzania and a West African country to be decided, and establish communications amongst users and suppliers of livestock statistics to pilot new methods for collection, validation and analysis of data and dissemination of indicators, which facilitate both public and private investments in the livestock sector. In developing new methods and approaches, the Project will (a) combine production, value chain and consumption data to better understand the livestock-poverty linkages; (b) identify key indicators that provide insights not only on production and productivity but also on other livelihood-supporting services provided by livestock; (c) take a demand-driven approach and design a targeted communication and advocacy strategy to support the mainstreaming of key livestock data / indicators into national statistical systems. What matters, in fact, is not the one-off generation and analysis of data, but the continuous availability of livestock statistics to identify good investment opportunities, either for the public and the private sector.
- PublicationThe Market For Animal-Sourced Foods In Tanzania: Business Opportunities For Small-Scale Livestock Producers?(International Farm Management Association (IFMA), 2013)
;Pica-Ciamarra, Ugo; ;Longin, NsiimaMtimet, NadhemDeveloping countries' consumption of high-value agricultural products, including animal-sourced foods, is anticipated to grow rapidly in the coming decades, fuelled by population growth, gains in real per capita income, and urbanization. Given that a large share of rural households in such countries keep some animals, a question arises as to whether the expanding market for animal protein represents a business opportunity for small-scale livestock producers. If consumers are anticipated to demand high-quality, highly-processed food products and do their shopping in supermarkets, there will be few opportunities for small-scale producers, who typically have insufficient human and financial capacity to meet that type of demand. Conversely, should consumers demand relatively low-quality and low-processed food products, then the growing market for animal-sourced foods will represent a major business opportunity for small-scale livestock producers. Available datasets and projections, however, while providing information on current and projected quantity of the different livestock products consumed at the commodity level, do not give details of preferred retail forms, outlets used and the desired safety and quality attributes. This paper presents the results of a rapid consumer survey undertaken by the Tanzanian Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries Development in collaboration with the World Bank-FAO-ILRI Livestock Data Innovation in Africa Project in Tanzania. The survey aimed at identifying preferred quality and safety attributes, retail forms and retail outlets for major livestock products and by type of consumers. Results of the survey, combined with nationally representative household datasets, allows describing both the quantitative and qualitative dimensions of the coming market for animal-sourced foods, which is anticipated to provide major business opportunities for smallscale livestock producers in the medium and short term. - PublicationQuestions that Count: A Livestock Module for Multi-topic Household Surveys(International Statistical Institute (ISI), 2013)
;Pica-Ciamarra, Ugo ;Zezza, Alberto; Morgan, NancyThe adequate inclusion of the major dimensions and determinants of livelihoods in multi-topic household surveys is essential for deriving appropriate measures of wellbeing and for effective investment design, implementation and evaluation. A review of existing Living Standards Measurement Study (LSMS) questionnaires reveals that livestock is largely neglected: they contain a limited set of questions on livestock, which focus ownership, and only infrequently inquire about animal health / diseases and on production of animal foods. This challenges the design and implementation of effective investments in the sector, despite about 60 percent of rural households in developing countries being fully or partly dependent on livestock for their livelihoods. This paper presents a short, a standard and an expanded version of a livestock module for multi-topic household surveys, jointly elaborated by the FAO, the ILRI (International Livestock Research Institute) and the World Bank. The standard version of the module consists of a set of questions that help quantify both livestock herd and the various contributions of farm animals to household livelihoods, including cash income, food, manure, draft power and hauling services, savings and insurance, and social capital. The expanded version contains additional questions on livestock characteristics (e.g. breeding, branding, etc.), husbandry practices (e.g. feeding, watering, etc.) and outputs (e.g. milk, dung, etc.) which, depending on the country, may or may not be included in the survey questionnaire. The short version consists of a minimum set of livestock-related questions, which is recommended be included in all LSMS survey questionnaires. Survey designers can adapt any of the three versions of the module to design a questionnaire that best suits their needs. The paper also illustrates examples from Niger, Tanzania and Uganda, where the livestock modules have been used to enhance the content of LSMS-type survey questionnaires, and discusses issues and options to further improve the livestock module for LSMS surveys. - PublicationInvesting in the Livestock Sector: Why Good Numbers Matter - A Sourcebook for Decision Makers on How to Improve Livestock Data(World Bank, 2014)
;Pica-Ciamarra, Ugo; ;Morgan, Nancy ;Zezza, Alberto ;Azzarri, Carlo ;Ly, Cheikh ;Nsiima, Longin ;Nouala, Simplice ;Okello, Patrick ;Sserugga, Joseph ;World BankUnited Nations, Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)This Sourcebook summarizes the outputs and lessons of the 'Livestock in Africa: Improving Data for Better Policies' Project. It aims to present the challenges facing professionals collecting and analysing livestock data and statistics and possible solutions. While the Sourcebook does not address all conceivable issues related to enhancing livestock data and underlining statistical issues, it does represent a unique document for a number of reasons. To begin with, it is possibly the first document which specifically addresses the broad complexity of livestock data collection, taking into consideration the unique characteristics of the sector. Indeed, in most cases livestock data are dealt with, if ever, within the context of major agricultural initiatives. Second, the Sourcebook is a joint product of users and suppliers of livestock data, with its overarching objective being to respond to the information needs of data users, and primarily the Ministries responsible for livestock in African countries and the National Statistical Authorities. Finally, the Sourcebook represents a unique experiment of inter-institutional collaboration, which jointly places the World Bank, the FAO Animal Production and Health Division, the ILRI and the Africa Union - Interafrican Bureau for Animal Resources as well as national governments in Niger, Tanzania and Uganda at the forefront of data and statistical innovation for evidence-based livestock sector policies and investments. This Sourcebook represents a first step towards a demand-driven and sustainable approach to enhance the livestock information available to decision makers. It is hoped it will provide a useable framework for significantly improving the quantity and quality of livestock data and statistics available to the public and private sector, and also increase the efficacy of investments that country governments and the international community allocate to generate information for livestock sector policies and investments. - PublicationConsumers' preferences for animal-source foods and retail outlets: The case of Tanzania(African Association of Agricultural Economists,Association Africaine des Agroeconomistes, 2016-09)
; ;Mtimet, Nadhem ;Pica-Ciamarra, UgoNsiima, LonginGrowth in population and income, as well as urbanisation, are contributing to the growing consumption of high-value foods in developing countries. However, public and private investments targeting high-value agricultural markets are constrained by limited information on the quality dimensions of the market, the nature of traditional retail formats, and consumer segmentation. This paper presents a simple and appropriate methodology to provide such information, and applies it in Tanzania to animal-sourced foods. It features a rapid survey, which is then aligned with nationally representative survey data. The results show that Tanzanian consumers demand, and are anticipated to continue demanding, relatively good-quality animal products but in rather low-valued product forms. Consumer segments are differentiated by level of wealth and by choice of retail format and retail product form, rather than by quality per se.
- PublicationConsumer Preferences for Animal Source Foods in Uganda: Quality, Retail Forms and Retail OutletsThis paper presents the results of a rapid consumer survey undertaken in Uganda. The survey aimed at identifying preferred quality and safety attributes, retail forms and retail outlets for major livestock products and by type of consumers. Results of the survey, combined with nationally representative household datasets, allows description of both the quantitative and qualitative dimensions of the developing market for animal-source foods, which is anticipated to provide major business opportunities for small-scale livestock producers in the short and medium terms.